Friday, December 7 2012, 10:54 PM MST
Supreme Court Takes Up Same-Sex Marriage
Washington (CNN) -- The Supreme Court will tackle the contentious issue of same-sex marriage, agreeing to hear two constitutional challenges to state and federal laws dealing with the recognition of gay and lesbian couples to legally wed.
In a one-page order on Friday, the court took on what will be one of the most important issues in its history. The decision to review the matter came just weeks after voters approved same-sex marriage in three states.
Oral arguments will likely be held in March with a ruling by late June.
One appeal to be heard involves the federal Defense of Marriage Act or DOMA, which denies federal benefits to same-sex couples legally married in their own state.
The second is a challenge to California's Proposition 8, a voter-approved referendum that took away the right of same sex-marriage that previously had been approved by the state's courts.
The political, social, and legal stakes of this long-simmering debate will once again put the high court at the center of national attention, a contentious encore to its summer ruling upholding the massive health care reform law championed by President Barack Obama.
There are about approximately 120,000 legally married same-sex couples in the United States.
Earlier this month, voters in Maryland, Washington, and Maine approved same-sex marriage, adding to the six states and the District of Columbia that already had done so. Minnesota voters also rejected an effort to ban such unions through a constitutional amendment.
Many other states, including New Jersey, Illinois, Delaware, Rhode Island and Hawaii, have legalized domestic partnerships and civil unions for such couples -- a step designed in most cases to provide the same rights of marriage under state law.
But other states have passed laws or state constitutional amendments banning such marriages. California's Proposition 8 is the only such referendum that revoked the right after lawmakers and the state courts previously allowed it.
In February, a federal appeals court in San Francisco ruled the measure unconstitutional. In its split decision, the panel found that Proposition 8 "works a meaningful harm to gays and lesbians" by denying their right to civil marriage.
The justices have discretion to rule narrowly or broadly on the aspects of the legal and procedural questions raised.
The federal case deals with Edith Windsor, who was forced to pay an estate tax bill much larger than other married couples would have to pay when her partner died. Because her longtime partner was a woman, the federal government, in legal terms, did not recognize the same-sex marriage even though their home state of New York did.
The federal law does not prohibit states from allowing same-sex marriages, but it also does not force states to recognize them from other states.
Other plaintiffs are federal workers, who are not allowed to add their spouses to health care plans, and other benefits.
Traditionally, the federal DOMA law would be defended by the Justice Department. But that responsibility would now fall to House Republicans after President Barack Obama declared his support for same-sex marriage earlier this year.
In their order on Friday, the justices specifically asked both sides to argue a supplemental question: Whether congressional Republicans -- operating as a bipartisan legal advisory group -- have "standing," or legal authority, to make the case.
The justices also asked both sides to argue a second standing question. California's governor and state attorney general have refused to defend Proposition 8 in court, leaving it to a private of coalition of groups supporting the law to file the appeals.
The high court could decide the standing question alone and dismiss the appeal without addressing the larger constitutional questions. That would mean for now, same-sex marriages could resume next year in California.
Those on both sides of the issue welcomed the high court's intervention.
"That the issue will soon be heard by the Supreme Court is a vindication of our work to achieve equal protection under the law for same-sex couples," said Mary Bonauto, director of the Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, who has been litigating the issue for decades. "This day has been long in the making, and we are committed to the success of this case."
But a group that helped lead the effort to pass Proposition 8 in California said it was confident of prevailing.
"We believe it is a strong signal that the court will reverse the lower courts and uphold Proposition 8," said John Eastman, chairman of the National Organization for Marriage. "That is the right outcome based on the law and based on the principle that voters hold the ultimate power over basic policy judgments and their decisions are entitled to respect."
The cases accepted Friday are Hollingsworth v. Perry (12-144), dealing with Proposition 8; and U.S. v. Windsor (12-307) on the DOMA issue.
In a one-page order on Friday, the court took on what will be one of the most important issues in its history. The decision to review the matter came just weeks after voters approved same-sex marriage in three states.
Oral arguments will likely be held in March with a ruling by late June.
One appeal to be heard involves the federal Defense of Marriage Act or DOMA, which denies federal benefits to same-sex couples legally married in their own state.
The second is a challenge to California's Proposition 8, a voter-approved referendum that took away the right of same sex-marriage that previously had been approved by the state's courts.
The political, social, and legal stakes of this long-simmering debate will once again put the high court at the center of national attention, a contentious encore to its summer ruling upholding the massive health care reform law championed by President Barack Obama.
There are about approximately 120,000 legally married same-sex couples in the United States.
Earlier this month, voters in Maryland, Washington, and Maine approved same-sex marriage, adding to the six states and the District of Columbia that already had done so. Minnesota voters also rejected an effort to ban such unions through a constitutional amendment.
Many other states, including New Jersey, Illinois, Delaware, Rhode Island and Hawaii, have legalized domestic partnerships and civil unions for such couples -- a step designed in most cases to provide the same rights of marriage under state law.
But other states have passed laws or state constitutional amendments banning such marriages. California's Proposition 8 is the only such referendum that revoked the right after lawmakers and the state courts previously allowed it.
In February, a federal appeals court in San Francisco ruled the measure unconstitutional. In its split decision, the panel found that Proposition 8 "works a meaningful harm to gays and lesbians" by denying their right to civil marriage.
The justices have discretion to rule narrowly or broadly on the aspects of the legal and procedural questions raised.
The federal case deals with Edith Windsor, who was forced to pay an estate tax bill much larger than other married couples would have to pay when her partner died. Because her longtime partner was a woman, the federal government, in legal terms, did not recognize the same-sex marriage even though their home state of New York did.
The federal law does not prohibit states from allowing same-sex marriages, but it also does not force states to recognize them from other states.
Other plaintiffs are federal workers, who are not allowed to add their spouses to health care plans, and other benefits.
Traditionally, the federal DOMA law would be defended by the Justice Department. But that responsibility would now fall to House Republicans after President Barack Obama declared his support for same-sex marriage earlier this year.
In their order on Friday, the justices specifically asked both sides to argue a supplemental question: Whether congressional Republicans -- operating as a bipartisan legal advisory group -- have "standing," or legal authority, to make the case.
The justices also asked both sides to argue a second standing question. California's governor and state attorney general have refused to defend Proposition 8 in court, leaving it to a private of coalition of groups supporting the law to file the appeals.
The high court could decide the standing question alone and dismiss the appeal without addressing the larger constitutional questions. That would mean for now, same-sex marriages could resume next year in California.
Those on both sides of the issue welcomed the high court's intervention.
"That the issue will soon be heard by the Supreme Court is a vindication of our work to achieve equal protection under the law for same-sex couples," said Mary Bonauto, director of the Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, who has been litigating the issue for decades. "This day has been long in the making, and we are committed to the success of this case."
But a group that helped lead the effort to pass Proposition 8 in California said it was confident of prevailing.
"We believe it is a strong signal that the court will reverse the lower courts and uphold Proposition 8," said John Eastman, chairman of the National Organization for Marriage. "That is the right outcome based on the law and based on the principle that voters hold the ultimate power over basic policy judgments and their decisions are entitled to respect."
The cases accepted Friday are Hollingsworth v. Perry (12-144), dealing with Proposition 8; and U.S. v. Windsor (12-307) on the DOMA issue.
News Photos & Videos - Submit Your Photos Here
![]() |
![]() |
More National Stories
Residents Of Tornado-Ravaged Texas Town Returning Home
Car Crashes Into Parade, Dozens Injured
Broken Rail May Have Caused Train to Derail
Eyeing $600M Powerball Jackpot? You Have a Better Chance of Dying By Lightning
New Product Turns Smart Phone Into Stun Gun
IRS Official Denies Intentional Political Targeting, Lying To Congress
CDC: Fecal Contamination Often Found In Public Pools
Murder Charge Stuns Some Fans Of 'Kai The Hatchet-Wielding Hitchhiker'
Idaho Man In Court For Uzbekistan Terrorism Plot
Boston Bombing Suspect Left Message in Boat Where He Was Hiding
Source Says President to Name Werfel as Acting IRS Chief
Terrorism Charges Filed in Utah and Idaho Cases
David Beckham Announces Retirement
Man Hits the Jackpot in His Cookie Jar
College Grads Swimming in Debt
Passengers Weigh In on Airline Satisfaction
Arizona Woman Tries to Give Baby to Strangers
School Bus Carrying Special Needs Students Crashes
Government Issues New Rules for Drilling on Public Lands
Marshal Service Unable to Locate Past Witnesses, Possible Terrorists
Powerball Jackpot 3rd Highest in History
Deadly Tornadoes Tear Through Texas
'Angry' Obama Announces IRS Leader's Ouster After Conservatives Targeted
Alaska Volcano Spews Ash 20,000 Feet
Jodi Arias Faces Possible Death Penalty After Jury's Verdict
Republicans Raise Praise on Obama Over IRS Targeting
Imprisoned O.J. Simpson Testifies In Bid For New Trial
Gosnell Sentenced To Life In Third Baby's Death
Angelina Jolie Undergoes Double Mastectomy
NTSB Recommending Lower Alcohol Limits
Obama Calls Alleged IRS Political Targeting
Suspect Identified In New Orleans Parade Shooting
Verdict Reached In Trial Of Abortion Doctor
Judge: Good Cause for Insanity Plea in Aurora Shootings
New Video Shows Police Breaking Into Castro's Cleveland Home
19 People Injured In Mothers Day Parade Shooting
DNA Confirms Kidnapper is Father of 6-Year-Old
4-Year-Old Chosen to Serve as Mayor of His Town
West, Texas First Responder Arrested
One Writer Spends a Year Without the Internet
Enron Executive's Possible Release From Prison Upsets Employees
Legal Marijuana Disappoints Financially
Spire Installed on New World Trade Center Building
Boston Suspect Burried in Virginia
Criminal Probe Launched Into West, Texas Explosion
Teen Charged With Murder in Georgia
Eight Charged in Cyber Heist
Witness: Michael Jackson Was Paranoid, Talking To Himself In Last Days
Bank Accused of Credit Card Collections Fraud
Most Common Baby Names Announced
'Iron Man' Sought in Bank Robbery
Castro Charged With Kidnapping, Rape In Ohio Missing Women Case
FCC Aims to Improve Internet on Airplanes
Women Flock To Landmines Event, Prince Harry Attends
YouTube Offers Paid Subscription Service
Review Prompts University to Revise Sexual Assault Policies
Search the Internet Like a Spy
Wife Accused of Hiring Hit Men to Kill Husband
Goats Put to Work at Airport
Boston Suspect's Body Entombed









